Showing posts with label Product Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Product Reviews. Show all posts

Saturday, 19 March 2016

Review: SHOWER'S PASS Rogue Hoodie


In my search for a new waterproof jacket this winter, I had a look at the current offerings from Showers Pass. While in the end I went with a Craft 'cycling specific' waterproof jacket, I also bought a second jacket intended for more general purpose use off the bike but also suitable for casual cycling: Shower Pass's Rogue Hoodie.

The Showers Pass website describes the Rogue Hoodie thusly: 

A street wise, bike friendly, and fiercely weather resistant technical hoodie, the Rogue Hoodie is like your favorite sweatshirt, in a flattering women's cut. The Rogue features a 3-layer waterproof softshell Artex material: the cozy fleece lined fabric wicks sweat away from skin, while the outer fabric and waterproof membrane keep wind and light rain at bay (seams are not sealed). 

An employee favorite here at Showers Pass, we wear the Rogue for fall and winter bike commuting, hiking, camping, on the slopes and around town – over a T-shirt when it’s 50 degrees, or layer up a few wool baselayers for colder conditions. Bike friendly features include a slightly dropped tail to protect against tire spray, longer sleeves with wrist gaiters, reflective accents, and a large back pocket with light loop.


The reference to Artex material meant little to me. ((Isn't Artex a material for covering walls?) My expectations to be honest were fairly vague and low:  basically a sweatshirt type jacket with some kind of weatherproofing. Not truly waterproof and certainly not breathable enough for 'spirited' prolonged riding, but cosier than your usual cycling waterproof jacket (most of which aren't designed to deal with chill as well as wet). 

I've got to say, this jacket has confounded and exceeded expectations in every way. I'll deal with specific features shortly but firstly I want to try and categorise this jacket, as I've never worn anything quite like it before. 

Saturday, 16 January 2016

Revisiting The "What To Wear" Winter Challenge


   
London cycling

Two of my very first posts after starting this blog covered my experiences and recommendations for clothing and accessories to keep yourself comfortably dry and warm enough to cycle through the winter. The commuting version is here, and the road cycling version is here. 

Three years on, my commute has changed so that it is, in fact, mostly road cycling -- with a 10-minute ride at the London end that can be done in pretty much any kind of clothing suitable for light exercise (comparable to walking) in whatever the weather conditions are on the day. The road cycling component of my commute (25-30 minutes inbound, 35-40 minutes outbound) however poses challenges in terms of temperature and moisture control. 

Cycle to Work Day, September 2014
(only a 3 mile ride to the train station,
so I tended to just half dress for the office)

I have been doing this new 12-mile roundtrip road commute for 10 months now. This is my first winter and I have wondered how "deep" into the winter I would get before feeling the need to take a few weeks off (perhaps six weeks at most... if I'm lucky) through the very worst of the winter with a view to restarting in the spring (early March... if I'm lucky). 

Saturday, 28 March 2015

All Wired Up

I have an ambivalent relationship with bicycle gadgetry. I've used cycling computers practically from the day I (re-)started cycling as an adult in 2009, but I've spent months at a time without any, and haven't had one on my main commuting bike for several years. I log a general estimate of commuting miles on the mycyclinglog website but am not really interested in any other data coming out of my daily commute.

On my 'good bike', however, I've always been interested in how far and fast I go -- though I am by means speedy nor am I what is known amongst audaxers as a 'Mileater'*. Nonetheless, the 'best bike' gets the best miles and I do like to know what I've been doing, in concrete as well as visceral terms.

The first few years, I used Cateye cyclo-computers. My first two computers (on the Brompton M3L) were wireless but found they sometimes fail to record what you're doing but likewise sometimes pick up interference from nearby devices, so just weren't reliable enough. I switched to wired versions and ran those on the Cross Check and Pacer quite happily. 
 



Thursday, 19 March 2015

Mini Reviews of Women's Bib Shorts - Some Brands "Get It", Some Don't

Some time ago, a discussion about womens bib shorts came up on the LovelyBicycle! blog. The usual issues were covered: lack of availability generally, lack of choice for sizes and body shapes and of course the inevitable challenge of the Toilet Break, or as some manufacturers delicately if somewhat obtusely put it, the "Bio Break"*. 

At some point in the middle of the discussion, I was struck with the impulse to dig out all the bib shorts I owned and take comparative photos. So I abandoned the computer for 15 minutes, dashed upstairs, upturned a few drawers, arranged various samples on the bed, snapped a couple of shots, then uploaded them to a photo website so that I could post a link to share with the other ladies in the discussion. On each of the two photos, I jotted down the brand and style name of each item, a link to where they can be bought (ideally where more details are provided directly by the manufacturer) and then a summary of what I personally thought of each pair. 

A suggestion was made that I blog about this myself. I certainly intended to but somehow it didn't really make it onto my To Do list. 

Fast forward to a few weeks ago when I had a clear-out of all the cycling kit that I don't wear regularly, for one reason or another. When it came to the bib shorts, I realised my experiences over the past few years have refined my preferences considerable, down to the point where I really only ever wear Gore branded bib shorts or bib longs.** So everything else went into the Outbound bag. And I decided it might be helpful to capture and preserve my "overviews" (not "reviews") in a more accessible place, i.e. here on the blog. 

So without further ado - I present a selection of bib shorts of various designs, highlighting where I think some manufactures have successfully figured out the whole Women's Bib Short "thing" and where others are just playing a Gimmick Game. 


Tuesday, 18 November 2014

Review: FASTRIDER Trolley Pannier


I may have found my perfect commuting bag!

A few months ago (after several months of commuting with my two-bikes-plus-train solution), the thought occurred to me, "Wouldn't it be great if I could pull this pannier along through train stations (between bikes) instead of carrying it?"

I seriously began going through my (extensive!) collection of wheeled holdalls, business cases and suitcases, looking for a suitable candidate that could be reinforced and to which I could fit pannier hooks (Klick-fix for preference).

And then I spotted this on ebay: 


Thursday, 6 November 2014

Review: CARRADICE STOCKPORT Bag for Brompton S-Type


I've had my Carradice Stockport bag for 18 months now so it's time for a long-term report and full review.

Features

As I mentioned in my preview of the Stockport, this bag is styled differently from the City Folder M. It is in Carradice's "Classics" range rather than the "Originals" range. This reflects the more refined look that the Stockport has, with styling a little more appropriate to city/business use than the more "audax-y" look of the Originals range! 


Sunday, 20 April 2014

Lucy Meets Yossi (A Nisnas Partnership)

You may recall my last update on Lucy the Brompton ending with mention of "one further modification to be made -- a purely cosmetic one!" 

Well, now I can reveal what it is:  

wooden fenders with steel inlays, beautifully crafted by hand by the
lovely chaps at Nisnas Industries in Israel [click HERE for details!]


Thursday, 13 March 2014

Errandonnee #5: There Will Be Days Like This


After a very foggy morning, it was worth the wait: glorious sunshine. One of the things on my To Do list is joining the local library, but when the wide outdoors are beckoning like this, I couldn't wait to try a "Library Without Walls" errandonnee.

Errandonnee #5
Date: Wednesday, 12 March 2014
Category: Library (Without Walls)
Destination:  Dunstable Downs Visitor Centre
Distance:  26.7 km
Steed: Riley the Enigma
What I learned/observations:


Wednesday, 26 February 2014

Review: VULPINE Mid-Calf Merino Socks


I bought a pair of Vulpine's merino socks from Velovixen at the London Bike Show a few weeks ago.

Sure, I already own more than my fair share of merino socks -- by De Feet, Smartwool, dhb and Icebreaker. But knowing what I know about how Vulpine's merino clothing is just so much softer and silkier than those of other brands, I had to give these a try.

They are, in a word, wonderful. Taller than any other "mid-calf" socks (of merino or any other persuasion) so I have no issues with a potential gap forming between the socks and my knee warmers. The soles are slightly thicker than the rest of the sock, especially under the heels, which gives a nice cushion when walking. The narrow red and navy stripes are made of a finer, tighter knit and contribute to a bit of shaping and a sense of support around the calves and the arches.


I adore them and fully intend to get another pair, perhaps next time in the knee-high polka dot version!

* Any perceived asymmetry can be blamed on my feet and/or how I put the socks on, not on the socks themselves! I really should learn how to line up the stripes...

Tuesday, 25 February 2014

Sneak Peak: THE NUTTER Bicycle Multi-Tool from Full Windsor


There's a new kid on the block:  Full Windsor. This is a cycle accessory brand with such an particular aesthetic that I'd have to also call it an aspirant lifestyle brand. Think urban hipster with a dash of steampunk. From that angle, it should hit the spot with a lot of Londoners! 

According to its website, Full Windsor is "the brainchild of Mark Windsor, a Kiwi product designer. He’s passionate about three things: riding bikes, designing imaginative bike products, and riding more bikes. You might say he’s a bit of a bike nut. And, along with a few other bike nuts, he started Full Windsor – a bicycle accessory design company led by innovation, hard work and a hell of a lot of mucking about on bikes. Full Windsor is based in a converted warehouse in the creative hub of Hackney Wick, right next to the Olympic stadium in east London."  

So what do they do? "Essentially they come up with new product ideas from behind the handle bars. The products are not your run of the mill, and that’s what they are all about - designing creative, functional products that users enjoy, which step outside the norm."

The key products in the range, to start with, have been easy fit mudguards, like this Foldnfix Mudguard: 




Full Windsor recently launched a new bicycle multi-tool kit called The Nutter and approached me asking me to review it. The product has been provided to me free of charge for review purposes. In line with my Product Review Policy, I have offered to return the product after testing but have not yet received Mark's reply on that. 



What Full Windsor say about The Nutter tool: 
"Featuring all the essentials for fixing your most common bike headaches. The Nutter combines all the tools you need when out riding into one simple unit. Its unique design and distinctive form turns the tool into a handle, giving you more leverage than other multi tools on the market. The tool weighs just 110g or 3.9oz."

The Nutter consists of a leather pouch (available in either 'burnt brown' or 'jet black') containing a range of separate tools (bits and drivers), each stored in a pocket made from recycled inner tube. Each bit or driver can be fitted into the side of a large metal handle, which itself incorporates a number of other tools and is designed for use as a tyre lever. The various tools included in the entire kit include: 
  • Nylon tyre lever
  • 15mm box head spanner
  • Spoke key
  • 3,4,5,6,8mm hex tool bits
  • Philips head screw driver
  • Flat head screw driver
  • T25 torx bit
  • Magnetic tool bit extender
  • Bottle opener
The product arrived in the post today. My first impression is that this is a high-quality piece of kit. Whether it warrants its asking price of £39.99 (slightly cheaper on sites such as Wiggle) remains to be seen.

I will be fitting The Nutter to the Brooks saddle on my Cross Check for general duties. Additionally, I will lend it to Adam to try out during his Dr. Bike sessions this coming week.

So watch this space for a full review coming soon.

** Photos above courtesy Full Windsor's website.

Thursday, 13 February 2014

The Right Tool For The Job



Until these floods and mud go away, I've decided to swap which cycling boots I wear. 

Above on the left are the Northwave Fahrenheit GTX (Gore-Tex) boots I've been using this year. On the right are the Shimano MW81 boots I wore last winter. 

Both are fabulous boots -- warm and waterproof and both fit well.

So why the switch?

Friday, 21 June 2013

Brooks Swallow Saddle - New Leather Top!

I bought my Surly Pacer at the end of March 2012. My chosen saddle was the Brooks Swallow - which is just gorgeous!

29 March 2012: brand spanking new out of the box

29 March 2012: the new build is complete


Wednesday, 8 May 2013

Update: TRAKKE BAIRN messenger bag, or, Customer Service Master Class



A few weeks ago, I put Alec Farmer of TRAKKE on the spot.

I wrote a product review on his company's smallest messenger bag, the Bairn, which included criticisms of how the shoulder strap had been fitted and the absence of a few cycling-specific features that I consider essential. And then I published that review for the world to see. And only then did I let him know about my complaints -- by posting a link to my review on TRAKKE's Facebook page.

This was all a bit unfair, I realise now, even considering that Alec and I had several exchanges by e-mail before I ordered the bag and from that, he may already have been aware that I write a cycling blog with a slight fixation on reviewing messenger bags!

In any event, Alec read that review and e-mailed me that very afternoon.

Wednesday, 1 May 2013

Review: VULPINE WOMEN'S ALPINE merino cycling jersey

The big news in womens' cycling gear this week is the launch of Vulpine's long-awaited womens' range.



I hit Vulpine's website almost as soon as I heard the news and was gutted to find that the new cycling-specific jersey (the Alpine) had already sold out in my size and preferred colour (claret).

Fortunately Velo Vixen announced the next day that they'd just taken delivery of stock across the entire range. I quickly ordered the Alpine in claret.

It arrived this morning.

Friday, 12 April 2013

Review: TRAKKE BAIRN messenger bag



I recently purchased the Trakke Bairn messenger bag (referenced at the bottom of my 2 February 2013 post).

Trakke is a small company in Glasgow that hand-makes messenger bags and backpacks aimed at cyclists primarily but also walkers/hikers/outdoor adventurers!  The man at the helm is Alec Farmer and the man at the (sewing machine) wheel is a former sail maker. Their philosophy and aesthetics focus on producing bags that are robust and functional, with a nod to local heritage -- most conspicuously displayed in the use of Harris Tweed. (I love the blog entry written by one of the weavers!)

So after a few weeks, here are my thoughts and impressions on the Bairn messenger bag.

Monday, 8 April 2013

Preview: CARRADICE STOCKPORT CITY FOLDER - new luggage option for Brompton S type!



Carradice have at long last designed a front bag for the Brompton S type folding bicycle.

As Brompton owners will know, the S type has a shorter stem and thus lower-positioned handlebar than any of the other Brompton "types". This means bags made for those other types are too tall for best function, with some safety concerns.

Wednesday, 27 March 2013

Saturday, 23 March 2013

It's Not The Weather, It's Your Gear... Road Cycling Edition

I prepared this post yesterday. Then it snowed again last night. And there has been further fettling and test rides on the mixte - all of which warrant another post which will be up shortly. 

*************************************

Further to my January post on clothing and kit to keep you warm and dry for winter commuting, here is a photo of a my typical winter road cycling gear.

The key differences in what's important when commuting versus getting out on the road and putting some long miles in are (a) temperature and moisture management and (b) wind chill, as you're expending more effort (= more sweat!) at higher speed (= may feel colder, especially when you stop!)

So I don't usually wear my waterproof overtrousers out on the road. I may get a little damp in the rain, but most winter tights are water resistant enough and I'd rather layer up with breathable fabrics to keep warm, than "boil-in-a-bag" yet shivery inside waterproofs.

Also, on my road bike I wear cycling boots for clipless pedals. 

This photo was taken a few weeks ago. The temperature was around freezing (0-1C) and we had some light snow flurries. I cycled to Harpenden for my Pilates class and the monthly farmers market - a round trip of 13 miles which is mostly downhill outbound, mostly uphill homebound.


From head to foot, skin to outer, I wore: 
  • Trek Windstopper headband  
  • Smartwool merino beanie  
  • Merino Buff  
  • Endura crewneck longsleeve merino baselayer 
  • dhb Ladies Vaeon Zero Padded Bib Tight  
  • Smartwool longsleeve full-zip merino jersey   
  • Gore Bike Wear Windstopper jacket  
  • Gore Bike Wear Power SO Lady Gloves  
  • Stretchy tube skirt (from Primark)    
  • DeFeet Wooleater ankle socks  
  • Shimano MW81 boots

Monday, 11 March 2013

Review: TIMBUK2 CLASSIC MESSENGER XS (Custom)


This is Timbuk2's Classic Messenger Bag.

Firstly, you're probably eyeing this and thinking "no way is that colour scheme in the shops".

And you'd be right.

You may recall my initial frustration (okay, 'rant') that, prior to buying my first messenger bag, I was curious about how useful and comfortable they really are, but was really put off by the limited colour choices and, let's face it, masculine aesthetics (all too often that dark, gritty, 'urban road warrior' look). 

Looking around, a few Timbuk2 messenger bags looked promising in terms of function (and positive feedback by my fellow lady blogger Cycling In Heels intrigued me further) but again... ugh! what uninspiring colours!

But I had only been looking at websites of UK-based online retailers, like Wiggle. When I visited Timbuk2's own website, I discovered.... the Custom Bag option! 

What a revelation!  While the bag itself can't be altered much in terms of basic design (size, pockets, etc), you can -
  • choose the colour (even fabrics) for each of the three panels that are an integral part of the Classic Messenger's signature look;
  • choose the colour of the binding/trim;
  • choose the colour of the interior lining;
  • choose the colour of the Timbuk2 logo on the front (make it as subtle as you like!);
  • specific whether you wear your bag over your left shoulder or your right;
  • add a larger reflector tab at the end of the straps that close the bag;
  • add a compression strap on the bottom of the bag; and
  • add on (at extra cost)
    - a shoulder strap pad (customised if you wish to match the colour/fabric of your bag);
    - a pocket at the back of the interior;
    - a grab handle on top of the bag;
    - other various accessories as part of your order (each of which are also available for sale separately).
So I thought:  if there's a chance I'm going to like this bag (and the odds look good), then I'm going to get something I not only love for its function but love for its looks.   So here it is.

My order specification was:


Secondly -- and if you've been reading my other messenger bag reviews, you'll know how crucial this is --this is the "XS" size of the Classic Messenger.  It measures 22.5 cm in height; the width is 32.5 cm at the top but tapers down to 26.5 cm at the bottom; and the depth is 13 cm. This is very comparable to the Michaux Club Tan Commuter bag (23 cm high x 33 cm wide x 9 cm deep), which I totally love.  [Just for context, the Large Classic Messenger is 30 cm high, 57 cm tapering to 41 cm wide and 23 cm deep!]

Features

This is the front, with the bag closed -


And the rear -


Single strips of fabric are used right over the front and back of the bag -


I think this is a nice touch, producing fewer seams that can rub/wear. And if you've chosen a patterned fabric in the Custom Bag option, the pattern will be continuous. The one downside is that pattern matching is not carried across over all the panels -- it would have been nice if the pattern in the two side panels of my bag had matched up or, even better, mirrored each other. But that would have added a lot of time and cost to what is probably a fairly automated manufacturing process.

Moving on, there is a strap on the front (below the flap) to mount a rear light -


If you go the Custom Bag route, you can opt for reflective trim. 
(And as you'll see a few photos further along, this same trim is used throughout, even on the interior!)


The bag closes with two methods:  straps with buckles over the outside of the bag, and also Velcro(R) strips underneath the flap.  Both methods work well. In fact, either on its own would be good enough.  With both, there is no way to avoid using the Velcro, regardless of whether or not you then leave the buckles undone.  If I could choose just one, I'd have the straps and buckles. I find that sometimes in a hurry, I close the bag and then find that the seams of the panels in the flap don't line up with the seams of the panels on the bag.  The straps are more forgiving in this regard (if the Velcro weren't there).  The Velcro strips are also incredibly loud, when opening the bag.  Timbuk2 do sell, separately, "Silencer Strips" that you can fix over the Velcro to put them out of commission -- if you don't like the mess, or the noise, or both. Removing the strips re-instates the Velcro function whenever you wish.

Having said that, there is perhaps one minor downside to relying on just the straps and buckles, and that is the material of the straps. It is a little on the slippery or silky side. I have found a few times that they loosen a bit on their own.  (So maybe that Velcro is good insurance after all.)

Under the flap is an organisation area on the front of the main body of the bag. This comprises a zip pocket (which has Timbuk2's signature red ribbon key tether inside), with a slip pocket above that. I think Timbuk2 has this configuration of pockets pre-made as a kind of pouch, ready to sew onto the bag as a unit. I understand pocket unit for the larger size messenger bags has more pockets - with the key tether inside the main body of the bag. (Can anyone confirm?)


Looking inside, you'll see a large main area, with a full-width slip pocket at the back of the bag. The divider used to create this pocket is lightly padded. (See the reflective lining!)


The slip pocket is not quite wide enough to fit A4 (or letter) sized papers inside, but the main bag is... just.


The lining is a type of vinyl or PVC - easy to clean by simply wiping it with a damp cloth. I chose a pale colour for contrast -- makes it easier to find the little things that inevitably settle at the bottom of your bag.

There is also a small zipped "Napoleon" pocket at the side of the organisation unit. This is designed for entry from the side, even while on the move.  [I will try and add a photo of this later.]

Moving on to the straps...

The shoulder strap is about 5 cm wide and made of nylon webbing of the sort used for car seatbelts. It is fixed at one end -- although there is also a ring sewn in just below where the strap is attached.  At the other end, the strap feeds through what I believe is called a Cam fastener. It has a looped section that lifts up to loosen the strap and then presses down again to secure the strap at the length you've chosen.  The Cam doesn't have a definite click-down feel to it, so I wonder how secure it really is but so far I haven't had the strap slip on me - so far so good. 

Meanwhile, I like how the Cam is shaped -- curvy with no hard edges (unlike the Knog Big Dog -- you could hurt yourself with that one!)



It may not be 100% clear from the photos above what happens to the excess length of shoulder strap. The bag was delivered with that end of the strap looped through a buckle that is fixed to the end of the bag below the Cam.  I re-threaded it through the buckle in such a way that I could loop the excess length round and round inside itself. This produces a smaller 'package' at the side of the bag and means there is no loose end to flap around.

And now for one of my  favourite features of messenger bags...  uh oh, it's not there!

I'm talking about the anti-swing strap. Timbuk2 say "XS bag does not include and is not compatible with the cross strap."  "Not compatible?" I say, "Rubbish!". 

I've examined how the cross strap is attached to the size S version of this same bag and see no reason why the same can't be done with the XS. And guess what - I had no difficulty attaching the anti-swing strap from my Michaux Club bag (of very similar size). It works just fine.



Timbuk2 could easily offer this as an optional extra -- at a charge as with the grab handle, if they wish.  Meanwhile, they do sell these straps separately. I suspect they're intended for purchase to use with the larger bags, but I'm tempted to get one and try it with the XS. (At US$5, why not?)

Meanwhile, another bag manufacturer (in Glasgow - much closer to home) that I'm interested in makes an XS size messenger bag that also doesn't come with an anti-swing strap. But.... they'll make one for it, on request and on payment of a surcharge for extra material and labour.

Performance

The basic bag has to be fit for purpose and do what it's supposed to. 
The Classic Messenger comes up trumps.   I think a few photos tell the tale.





The stock version will certainly perform just as well. So do you need to get a custom version?

     If you're left handed or for some other reason want the strap to go over your right shoulder...

     If you really need a grab handle on the top of the bag...

     ...then, yes, you'll need to go custom to get those things.

Otherwise, it comes down to personal taste and priorities. I did not want to buy a well-designed bag, really like the way it performed but have to resign myself with living with ugly colours.  I don't need a 'designer' look. To be honest, I'd have been perfectly happy to find a stock bag in solid red... or red and white... or dark pink and white. But red only comes in combination with grey (which makes the whole thing look grubby). And there is no pink in the stock inventory.

So, yes, I've paid a premium for little more than style. When I saw the opportunity to do that, I decided to make this bag as individual and unique as I could.  On the one hand, that means this was a bit of a vanity project. On the other hand, without the option to create my own custom bag, I would not have purchased from Timbuk2 at all.  I guess that's what we call a win-win.

VERDICT

Cycling-specific design features: 9 / 10

Usefulness e.g. accessibility and comfort: 9 / 10 
   [My only slight reservation whether water can get into the top of the bag. I find the Velcro a bit annoying. But that can be resolved.]

Durability:  8 / 10
   [Time will tell how stain resistant these fabrics are, and how easy the bag is to clean. Otherwise, the bag is sturdy and looks well made. Used examples on Ebay seem to hold up well.]

Attractiveness:  9 / 10 
   [Hard to score low, when you can have so much control over this!]

Value for money: 9/ 10 
   [Standard bags are available for under £60 if you look. That is extremely competitive in this market. Used bags seem to hold their value on Ebay as well.]





Overall:  44 / 50


*************************

My reviews of other messenger bags can be found: 

Saturday, 9 March 2013

A look at the KNOG BIG DOG

Up next in my series of messenger bag reviews:  the Knog Big Dog


I must not be understanding the dimensions given on websites very well, as yet again here is a bag that is just so much bigger than I had visualised, so much so that I struggle to get my head round it.

(For what it's worth, I think the colour here is "stone".)

Here's what the manufacturer says about the Big Dog... and what I found for myself.
"Fat and roomy". In other words, HUGE. Alarm bells should have been ringing at the outset.



The strap is described as "extra wide".
Indeed it is TOO wide. Too wide to manage with my size hands, at least. Too wide, too thick, too heavy to adjust easily (much less on the go). Which makes it unfit for purpose. And very uncomfortable. 



And then there's the "waist strap".

Somehow, in my world, this should have translated to "anti-swing" (or stability) - in practice if not by description. Instead, there is something that does indeed (or is intended to) "go round one's middle" but it'll hit your waist only if you're King Kong.  I can't even call this "going round my hips". Which means it is totally useless.


The bag also apparently has "easy access pockets".  From all my 'window shopping', I believe this is supposed to mean that you can get (in)to it while you're cyling, i.e. while moving. Tell me how you're supposed to get into the top one here.  And I can't find the side ones with my hands, with the bag on my bag either. In fact, I'm not sure they aren't total figments of a marketeer's imagination.




To flesh out the picture, here are close-ups of various features, illustrating, at the very least, that the bag is robustly made.

The velcro and "locks" fastening the outer flap down are strong. The downside is, while you can close/secure it in a hurry, getting it open is a big pain. Impossible while on the move.


The inside of the bag is largely un-reconstructed, with for a laptop sleeve at the back, a full-length slip pocket in front of it, and then two half-length slip pockets in front of that. The rest is open space.








This bag retails at $125 on Knog's own website. I've found it in the UK at £53.38 to £79.88. Some retailers indicate that the Big Dog bag has been discontinued (in this mutation at least) in the UK market but I haven't been able to find 'officially' confirmation of this.


VERDICT

Cycling-specific design features: 6 / 10
   [I'm awarding points more for thought/effort than anything - see next point!]
Usefulness e.g. accessibility and comfort: 2 / 10 
   [Even worse than the Ortlieb Zip City S that I reviewed here!]
Durability:  8 / 10
Attractiveness:  7 / 10 
   [Assuming this is your cup of tea. That pale colour will get filthy quickly.]
Value for money: 8 / 10 
   {Assuming you're otherwise happy e.g. with size etc.]


Overall:  31 / 50


Meanwhile, I'm still gobsmacked that the way manufacturers describe their product do not give potential buyers the information they need to formulate reasonable expectations before purchase.

*************************

My reviews of other messenger bags can be found: 
  • Michaux Commuter here
  • Ortlieb Zip City S here and here
  • Timbuk2 Classic Messenger XS (custom) here

Share This